Anderson University recorded 32 academic all-Heartland Collegiate Athletic Conference (HCAC) selections for the Fall 2023 season.

Academic All-Conference selections have at least a cumulative 3.5 GPA and are varsity athletes. The cumulative GPA is the student-athletes GPA at the end of the semester preceding the end of the fall season. The student-athlete must have completed the equivalent of a full academic year and must be a full-time enrolled student at the institution to be eligible for the Academic All-Conference award.

The award is named after Tom Bohlsen, who served as the HCAC's first commissioner from 1998 to 2008.

Men's Cross Country (4)

Kaleb Gucinski (Gr.)*

Gage Guenin (Jr.)^**

Tyler Nelson (So.)^*

Josh Soden (Sr.)^***

Women's Cross Country (5)

Lydia Dyer (Jr.)^**

Paige McKain (So.)^*

Mariah Sanders (Sr.)^***

Jaycie Sones (Jr.)^**

Baileigh Stewart (Jr.)^**

Men's Soccer (5)

Josh Brown (Sr.)^***

Stephen Fite (Sr.)^***

Brendan Hall (So.)^*

Cameron Knox (Jr.)^**

Jerrod Schlagel (So.)^*

Women's Soccer (13)

Hannah Caes (Sr.)^***

Lillie Casey (Jr.)^**

Rebekah Fannin (So.)^*

Meghan Foster (So.)^*

Holly Garrett (Jr.)^**

Caroline Hill (So.)^*

Izzy Jahjah (So.)^*

Emmalee Paarlberg (Sr.)^***

Kylie Roberts (Jr.)^**

Hannah Thompson (So.)^*

Isabella Trader (Sr.)^***

Adrienne Weyers (So.)^*

Mandy Williams (Sr.)*

Volleyball (5)

Cara Burkall (So.)^*

Lauren Dungan (Jr.)*

Kelsie Marker (So.)^*

Olivia Ricica (Jr.)^**

Kate Todd (Sr.)**

*indicates number of times received academic all-conference

^indicates student-athlete has received academic all-HCAC honors every year eligible